Have Chip and Joanna Gaines and that Pioneer Woman Ruined It All For You?

Ahh, that adorable Fixer Upper couple.

What’s not to love about Chip and Joanna Gaines, who have eased their way into our living rooms and hearts with their seemingly perfect marriage and uncanny knack for completely remodeling a home for like $8.53?

You wouldn’t have to watch the HGTV reality show Fixer Upper for long before you would be drooling over a move to Waco, Texas, where you could hire Chip and Joanna to give you a stunningly immaculate kitchen… and all their secrets to an equally beautiful marriage.

And those children?! How scrumptious are they?

I mean, the whole clan looks like they walked off that Pioneer Woman’s pristine ranch, well fed and well mannered, like they all just worked together to wrastle some cattle and then shared a home-cooked photo-worthy meal (served family style, of course).

Relax. I have nothing against Chip and Joanna. Or Pioneer Woman Ree Drummond, for that matter.

They seem like they would be good neighbors. I even once saw Ree Drummond and her husband Ladd in person, and I gotta admit, they seemed pretty down to earth.

So why did I title this, “Have Chip and Joanna Gaines and that Pioneer Woman Ruined it All For You?”

Because I think it is so tempting to think these people have perfect marriages. That they never argue (I mean real argue. Not TV argue). That they never struggle or feel discouraged with parenting issues or sex or finances or schedules. That they never get tired or annoyed.

Yeah, I don’t know anything about the particulars of their relationships (you know, because I don’t actually know them), but I think it is safe to say that we aren’t getting the whole picture when we tune in.

Reality shows have become entangled in our societal fabric, and much of that reality programming feeds our almost insatiable desire to consciously or sub-consciously compare other relationships to our own.  And we don’t even do a fair comparison at that, because we take the outside of their relationship and slam it up against the inside of ours.

When we gaze on reality shows that paint marriage only in a positive light, we are looking at a squeaky-clean portrayal of marriage.  Conversely, when we gaze at reality shows that paint marriage only in a negative light, we are looking at an over-dramatized portrayal bent on accentuating the worse possible aspects.

There are pa-lenty of reality shows that fall into both camps.

Producers and marketing executives are masterful magicians. They could not care less about what they are saying about marriage.  They care only about the number of viewers they can draw in this week.

And next week.

If millions of people weren’t in love with the Chip and Joanna Gaines they see on TV, Chip and Joanna wouldn’t be on TV.

know. You know this.

But it is worth discussing again, because I think too many people aren’t just entertained by these couples. They are enamored to the point of becoming steeped in discouragement with their own marriages. (Or with their own kitchens. But I digress).

I have no idea if Chip and Joanna Gaines, and Ladd and Ree Drummond have authentic marriages.  I would lean toward saying they do, BUT I don’t think that’s what we see on TV.

Authentic marriage is a mix of good and bad, difficult and easy, frustrating and exhilarating.  And let’s not kid ourselves. There is a whole lotta mundane thrown in there as well, even in the best of marriages. Even in Christian marriages.

Messiness. Loose ends. Kids that aren’t always obedient. Dogs that puke. Cars that don’t start. Holidays that don’t look like they were prepared for a magazine cover. Conversations that aren’t resolved in a 23-minute segment.

Some marriages face harder trials than others.  Even marriages that seem completely free of struggle rarely are.

If creators of reality TV put all that up on the screen, we’d probably be bored out of our minds. We’d probably be thinking, “Why do I want to watch this? It looks strikingly familiar to my own life.”

Average everyday marriage does not make for profitable popular programming. It just doesn’t.

Day-in day-out marriage doesn’t have the benefit of countless retakes and lighting adjustments and scripted “unscripted” moments that edge it all toward perfection before the closing credits roll.  It’s real tempting to let TV portrayal of marriage paralyze us from embracing the good in our own marriage and addressing where we can grow.

I was thinking about this when I was at a gathering and someone made a general inference about my marriage.  He gave a sarcastic laugh, looked my way and said, “Like you have any problems in your marriage.”

The bubble above my head said something like, “Um. Okay. You have no idea the struggles we navigate on a fairly consistent basis. No idea.”

One downfall of writing a blog about sex in marriage is that people assume my husband and I never have marriage struggles.

That seems like the craziest assumption ever to me, because… well… we are married.  I feel much about marriage is hard. And I don’t know about the rest of you, but I personally wouldn’t be able to name one couple that is all smiles as they try to remodel a bathroom together, let alone an entire house.

My point?

Enjoy and be entertained by Chip and Joanna and The Pioneer Woman.  But keep your self awareness in check, if you find yourself pining for a marriage like theirs.

When those cameras aren’t rolling, their marriages probably look a lot like other people’s marriages, a mix of easy and difficult, good and bad, heartwarming and disappointing.

Now, their kitchens, on the other hand… yeah… I’m not gonna lie.

I’m probably going to keep coveting their kitchens.

Copyright 2016, Julie Sibert. Intimacy in Marriage Blog. Links may be monetized.

4 thoughts on “Have Chip and Joanna Gaines and that Pioneer Woman Ruined It All For You?

  1. Melissa says:

    Ahh, I remember the days of evening game shows being on and then the takeover of TV programming with the reality shows. We got rid of our subscription TV because of all the trash that was on, but I do love to watch Fixer Upper on Netflix on occasion. Your post is a great reminder for couples not to fix their eyes on TV relationships in envy. After all, they are sinners just like the rest of us and surely don’t have this “perfect” marriage and family that is depicted on their shows.

  2. Joe says:

    Great post. I’m in the home improvement, remodel, kitchen & bath business… and we jokingly refer to HGTV as “homeowner porn”. Guess the actual construction work done on these shows isn’t the only part that doesn’t depict reality.

  3. OlderMarried says:

    I so enjoyed this post, because I have also often wondered about the mystique of this couple. In one episode, JoAnna said, “I can do that for you.” Chip replied, “That isn’t the only thing you can do for me tonight.” Hilarious, because she gave him this goofy, clueless look, but at the same time, it made me think of things I’ve said to my wife that she didn’t “get”, but maybe she just chose to ignore. Then, that night, I’d find out.

    The best marriage is the one you are in, and the one you can make better, in whatever ways it should be nurtured. Still, it’s fun to watch “Fixer Upper” turn old homes into beauties.

  4. Jason@SongSix3 says:

    It’s funny how people think marriage bloggers & mentors have somehow “arrived”. Matter of fact, it’s downright hilarious!

    No, we haven’t arrived. We’ve simply learned how to give some measure of grace and work together to get THROUGH our issues, instead of letting them create walls between us like they used to.

Leave a Reply