Does Your Husband Demand Certain Sex Acts?

Recently I received an email from a concerned wife whose husband was demanding she swallow his semen during oral sex.

This is just one of a variety of sexual demands that can show up in the marriage bed.

One person is insisting and the other person is resisting and this dynamic is causing horrendous discord, not just in bed, but in the marriage in general.

For this post, I’m referring to demands that could fall into the broad camp of “sexual variety.”

Certainly there are several spouses out there who are receiving no (or very little) sexual intimacy, and some have wondered if they can be more stern (or demanding?) in expressing their need for sexual attention.

That is a big topic.  For another post.

For today, I want to explore this matter of “demanding” certain sexual acts.

Other than someone ordering someone to do something, how else do we determine something is a demand?

Below are some indicators:

  • It is veiled as a request, but the tone and manner in which it is delivered suggest otherwise.  We know when we are being bullied rather than lovingly encouraged.
  • It is laced with the “If you really loved me, you would do this” phrase… a shiny wrapping paper that at its minimum is supposed to soften the blow and at the maximum is meant to corner someone into questioning the depth of their love. “Maybe my husband is right. If I really loved him, I would do this, right?”
  • It potentially pushes the envelope or clearly crosses boundaries of what is sexually acceptable from a biblical standpoint.
  • If the demand is not met, then there is punishment of some sort, usually of the passive-aggressive variety.  “Well, if you won’t do this, then we might as well not have sex at all.  I’ll just take care of things myself.”

We could go into lengthy debate as to why sexual demands even show up in a marriage.

My very unscientific theory would be we can trace demands right back to one or more of the below…

  • Past promiscuity (“My ex-girlfriend did this and I enjoyed it.”)
  • Pornography (“I saw this on-line [or heard about it] and I want to try it!”)
  • A desire to exert control  (“I will show her who is in charge.”)
  • Spiritual ignorance or carelessness (“What is her big hang up about this, anyway?!!”)
  • Immature communication skills (“I told her what I wanted. Doesn’t she hear what I’m saying?!”)

Sexual demands. Coercing someone into doing something they don’t want to do sexually.

I know this should go without saying, but if something is outside of God’s plan for sexual intimacy in marriage, then obviously the request/demand is sinful. Participating would be compromising on God’s standards.

While there are a variety of examples, the one that comes to my mind and heart the quickest is anything that would damage the exclusivity of the sexual relationship.  Threesomes, pornography, spouse swapping.  God’s Word is abundantly clear on why this sort of behavior is off limits.

But what about something that doesn’t fall outside God’s plan, but still is being presented as a demand upon a hesitant spouse?

Let’s look at this closer by using the example of the husband demanding his wife swallow his semen during oral sex.

I have heard from many a husband who say that it would mean so much to them to have their wife swallow.

They go into lengthy and heartfelt reasons. They would genuinely feel received and loved by their wife, they would emotionally feel closer in that moment, they would be able to enjoy the oral pleasure to its fullest, and so on.

Those are all valid expressions of why they like it — and we could easily put those reasons on many sexual variety circumstances.  In fact, those whys listed above all are rooted in genuine God-honoring emotions, right?  I have a few whys of my own as to some things I enjoy sexually with my husband.

The problem arises when the why — even a God-honoring why — drifts into justification for turning a sexual request into a sexual demand.

We are diving into treacherous waters whenever we demand something sexually that our spouse clearly has reservations about.

Pleasure at all costs can hardly be what God envisioned, right?

“But the Bible doesn’t say oral sex is wrong!  The Bible doesn’t say a wife swallowing her husband’s semen is wrong!”

Such pleas, though ringing with rock-solid truth, are hopelessly hollow when we sift them through these verses:

Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.” (1 Corinthians 13:4-7)

“[The Word of God] judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart. Nothing in all creation is hidden from God’s sight. Everything is uncovered and laid bare before the eyes of him to whom we must give account.”  (Hebrews 4:12-13)

Love must always be our guiding compass.

Requesting something in a tone of love? I don’t see anything wrong with that.  Demanding it?  Well, obviously by this point in the post, you know what I think about that.

And just for the record, lest anyone think I’m picking too harshly on husbands who are demanding certain sexual acts, I do think we as wives must always sift our refusals through those above verses as well.

Again, I’m talking about sexual requests that do not fall outside God’s parameters for sexual intimacy in marriage.

If you are refusing something simply to be spiteful or manipulative — rather than because of legitimate concerns, reservations or difficulties — then I think your refusal grieves God’s heart too.

Just as a request should be made with a heart motive of love and kindness, a refusal should be given with the same tone of authentic love.

Deep abiding sexual intimacy is drenched in open, vulnerable and compassionate communication.

God’s always looking at the motive of the heart. Always.

Copyright 2012, Julie Sibert. Intimacy in Marriage Blog.

52 thoughts on “Does Your Husband Demand Certain Sex Acts?

  1. Kelley says:

    I’m so glad I’m not alone! In the beginning of our 18 year marriage I started out giving my husband oral but my gag reflex is so bad I had to stop. We still had sex on a regular basis so I thought we were good and we were affectionate outside the bedroom. He did want me to initiate it more, but that was difficult for me, especially since we seldom go on dates and I was taking care of everything and falling into bed exhausted and feeling like an afterthought. I still should have tried harder. After he had a 2 1/2 year emotional affair, he started requesting oral again and asked for anal, which I had said no to early on in our marriage. Because of his other relationship it was difficult for me to be intimate with him, but because I wanted to win him back (he kept going back to her and after almost five years still seeks her out at our son’s ball games and stares at her so I quit going), I tried to be more sexual. He wants me to not only be willing to do oral and anal, but also like it and ask for it. I hate them both! He has held my head down during oral so he can come but then I throw up. He wants me to swallow but I find it gross. I’m also sensitive to smells so oral is also hard for me unless he’s freshly showered or I gag right away. He wants me to give oral after we’ve done vaginal sex, and I don’t want my mouth on something that was just inside me. I’m willing to have sex whenever and in whatever position he wants. We use toys and try to be adventurous in other ways. I’m no prude, but I hate oral and anal. He watched porn before we were married and he saw those women do it and enjoy it and doesn’t understand why I don’t. He’s started to resent me over this and after I come he just stops and thinks and then shakes his head and gets out of bed. Today he told me he’s thinking about how he wants to come oral/anal because it’s more intense. Because he’s not getting it he doesn’t come at all. Two years ago he said he doesn’t love me and a few months later said he wanted a divorce. I don’t know how much it’s tied to the other woman, how much of it is our sex life and how much is just him. He won’t kiss me or give me any affection or attention. He refuses to wear a wedding ring, won’t tell me I’m beautiful or anything to affirm me, but I’m supposed to do something uncomfortable at best painful and Degrading at worst? There is no romance or intimacy and he won’t do anything with his family but sees this woman at work and baseball practice every day. I’m stuck in marriage hell and I want any sex less and less. I don’t know what to do but feel like he’s furious with me for not giving in more. He knows my feelings but thinks I should just suck it up. Afterwards he just turns over and goes to sleep. I feel used, lonely, degraded, rejected and unloved. Our sex life used to be good, but he gives me no grace or mercy whatsoever. I don’t know what to do. If I thought anal sex would save our marriage that would be one thing, but at times he yells at me and is emotionally abusive and is an angry person. I’m not motivated in bed when I’m unloved and unimportant.

  2. Scott says:

    Kelley, This is way after your post. Sorry to hear what you are going through. While oral and anal are part of the topic at hand, there are some serious underlying hurts and issues going on in your relationship. He can ask/demand all he wants for those acts but if you gave him those even with passion and desire, it would not fix the other issues. Fix the other issue and the desire or at least being ok with the acts may come. I am a guy and from what I read above, this is a bigger/deeper relationship issue. God bless on a solution.

Leave a Reply